Contact requests open soon. In the meantime, use the guides and the free summary.

SIDE-BY-SIDE COMPARISON

Consumer proposal vs debt consolidation in Canada

Both can be described as a simpler payment, but they are fundamentally different ways of dealing with debt.

THE SHORT ANSWER

A consolidation loan replaces selected debts with new borrowing that must be repaid. A consumer proposal is a formal process administered by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee, with terms put to creditors. A lender enquiry is not a proposal assessment or filing.

Explore my consumer-proposal options

First separate borrowing from an insolvency process

FCAC describes consolidation as combining debts through products such as a loan or line of credit. The OSB describes a consumer proposal as a formal arrangement administered by an LIT. The shared idea of one payment does not make the eligibility, credit consequences or legal process interchangeable.

Compare the type of help
QuestionConsolidation loanConsumer proposal
Who handles it?The lender or authorized borrowing intermediaryA Licensed Insolvency Trustee
Is there new borrowing?YesNot a replacement loan
What sets the payment?The lending agreementThe proposal terms and formal process
What needs individual review?Approval, total cost and securityEligibility, debts, assets, terms and consequences

For a loan, compare full cost and sustainability

Prepare a list of the balances to be paid and obtain quotes for a realistic repayment period. Ask whether the payment is lower because of a better rate or because repayment has been stretched out. If the new borrowing is secured, identify the asset at risk. A lender willing to advance money has not necessarily resolved the pattern that created the original balances.

For a proposal, ask an LIT what applies to you

An LIT needs to assess your actual circumstances and explain the available options. Do not assume that a website’s debt amount bracket proves eligibility or establishes how much you would repay. Ask which debts are included, how assets and joint obligations are treated, and what happens if the proposed payments become difficult.

Bring the same facts to both conversations

Use the same debt list, income picture and essential expenses so you are not comparing answers based on different information. Record the assumptions behind any quoted payment. Do not stop creditor payments or assume collection protection merely because you completed an enquiry. A formal filing and a contact request are different events.

Prepare for a conversation

  • A complete debt list, including secured and joint debts.
  • Reliable income and essential expenses.
  • The total repayment and assumptions for each option.
  • The professional’s explanation of credit and legal consequences.

You do not need account numbers, a SIN, banking credentials or uploaded documents to start our enquiry.

Should I apply for a loan before speaking to an LIT?

There is no universal sequence. You can ask questions about your options before committing to borrowing or a formal proceeding. If payments are already unsustainable, make that clear in the assessment.

Make your next step about your situation

Start a free DebtHelpers enquiry. No credit check in this form and no obligation to accept a service. Choose your contact preference before reviewing permission.

Explore my consumer-proposal options

Looking for a different kind of help?

Choose this path if you want to discuss replacement borrowing instead.

I want a consolidation-loan enquiry

Sources & review status