COMPARISON GUIDE

Debt consolidation vs a debt management plan in Canada

Both options can involve one payment, but they are not interchangeable. The key distinction is whether you are taking new credit or arranging repayment through a counsellor.

  1. 01Name the pressure
  2. 02Compare the routes
  3. 03Check the trade-offs
  4. 04Prepare your questions
  5. 05Take the next step
Hands organizing a simple household budget beside a calculator and a small stack of papers
Start with one billPick the bill that feels hardest today. Then take one step at a time.

IN PLAIN WORDS

Start with the payment that is hardest to make. Then look at each choice, its cost, and what it may change.

Find my repayment options

KNOW THE DIFFERENCE

A loan and a repayment plan are not the same.

Start with how each works, who provides it and what to ask.

Consolidation loan

New borrowing used to pay existing balances.

Who to speak with
A lender or appropriately authorized broker
A useful question
What is the total repayment, including interest and fees?
Understand this option

Debt management plan

A voluntary repayment arrangement with participating creditors.

Who to speak with
A credit counselling organization
A useful question
Which creditors participate, and what fees apply?
Understand this option
PART 01

Consolidation: a new credit product

Read the key facts before you choose.

Read the full details

Consolidation: a new credit product

A consolidation loan pays off balances using new borrowing. Approval and terms come from the lender. Compare the complete repayment cost, not only the advertised monthly payment.

PART 02

Debt management plan: an arrangement with creditors

Start with the bill that is hard to pay.

Read the full details

Debt management plan: an arrangement with creditors

A counsellor proposes a repayment arrangement to creditors. You usually repay the full debt; interest relief and creditor participation are not guaranteed. A plan may carry fees and does not cover every debt. It is not the same as a consumer proposal.

PART 03

How are they different?

See what is the same and what is not.

Read the full details

Compare the same facts for both options

Ask for the debts included, payment schedule, total cost, credit implications and consequences of a missed payment. Put the answers side by side. “One lower payment” is not enough information to decide which route deserves a closer look.

What to have ready

  • Is new borrowing involved?
  • Which debts remain outside the arrangement?
  • What is the full cost, including service fees?
  • What happens if your income falls or you miss a payment?

You do not need account numbers, your SIN, bank passwords, or files to start.

Which route does this page send my enquiry to?

You choose. The primary button requests guidance about a debt management plan; the separate consolidation button starts a borrowing enquiry. Neither button means that a provider has accepted you or that a plan has begun.

Put many debt payments into one clear plan.

Start with the bills you have now. Then compare a debt plan with your other choices.

Find my repayment options

Looking for a different kind of help?

Choose this separate path if you want to explore borrowing to combine existing balances.

Find my consolidation options
WHERE WE CHECKED THE FACTS

Sources

Show sources